Menu
UPPER ARKANSAS WATER CONSERVANCY DISTRICT
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Resources
  • Meet Our People
  • Augmentation
    • Augmentation Services
    • Reading Your Water Meter
    • Submit Your Meter Reading
    • Update Contact Info
    • Payments
    • Augmentation Data Login
  • Meeting Information
    • Public Notices & Meetings
  • Our Water
    • WATER TALKS PODCAST
    • Local Water News
    • Projects
    • Water Resource Data
  • News & Information
    • Water Terms
    • Calendar
    • Links & Resources
  • WATER CONSERVATION PROGRAM
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Resources
  • Meet Our People
  • Augmentation
    • Augmentation Services
    • Reading Your Water Meter
    • Submit Your Meter Reading
    • Update Contact Info
    • Payments
    • Augmentation Data Login
  • Meeting Information
    • Public Notices & Meetings
  • Our Water
    • WATER TALKS PODCAST
    • Local Water News
    • Projects
    • Water Resource Data
  • News & Information
    • Water Terms
    • Calendar
    • Links & Resources
  • WATER CONSERVATION PROGRAM

Water Talks: Nestle Waters & Augmentation

7/15/2020

2 Comments

 

WATER RIGHTS PROTECTIONS & NESTLE WATER’S 
RUBY MOUNTAIN SPRINGS AUGMENTATION

BY: Ralph “Terry” Scanga, General Manger, UAWCD

Over the past 20 plus years I have written many articles on water rights and water allocation in Colorado.  However, since so much of our current population is relatively new and therefore unfamiliar with Colorado’s water Doctrine, it may serve the District and all of us well to review that Doctrine and especially with the Nestle Water’s 1041 renewal permit approval pending in Chaffee County.
 
The Colorado Doctrine is quite simple.  The waters of the State belong to the people subject however to appropriation by individuals or entities for beneficial use.  Beneficial use is municipal (drinking), irrigation of crops, industrial uses, recreation, and environmental.  Recreational and environmental uses can only be appropriated by specific public entities and are a relatively new addition to the types of recognized beneficial uses.  Since Colorado and especially the Arkansas Basin is an arid State and Basin adjudicated water rights each have a priority date based upon the first date of diversion.  That is “First in Time is First in Right”.  However, since 1969 when tributary ground water was integrated under this system, like surface water has been since statehood, one could divert or pump ground water only if he replaced the water used-up at a location above the shorted water right.  There are some exemptions to this law, but they relate primarily to historic residential/home uses.  This replacement practice and plan also must be adjudicated by the water court and undergo extensive scrutiny before being approved.  These plans are called “Augmentation Plans”.
 
Nestle Water’s Ruby Mountain Springs’ wells have operated pursuant to the Upper Arkansas Water Conservancy District’s umbrella augmentation plans since 2015.  All the water used-up by Nestle has been replaced in the Arkansas River under this plan and by new water brought into the basin from the Western Slope of Colorado.  There have been no negative impacts or injury to the flows or water rights by the Nestle well pumping and use.  In fact, due to the Chaffee County 1041 permit conditions and terms, Nestle water replacements have enhanced flows in the Upper Arkansas river.  Under State water administration rules and laws water depleted in an augmentation plan must only be replaced above the shorted water right.  In the case of Nestle depletions, the replacement water does not have to be new trans-basin water and could be replaced out of Pueblo Reservoir, thus bypassing the Upper Arkansas portion of the River.
 
The former owner of Nestle Water’s Ruby Mountain Springs was impounding water for fish propagation under a decree that was non-consumptive.  However, the water impoundments were causing depletions to the river and injured water rights.  Today the Division of Water Resources is scrutinizing out of priority uses that are causing injury to river flows and water rights in the Upper Arkansas area.  These uses are primarily illegally filled catchments such as ponds built for fish propagation and aesthetics.  The amount of annual depletions is large.  More importantly, the major portion of these unsanctioned depletions occur during summer irrigation months of July and August.  Each acre of surface in these open-water ponds can create more than 3-acre feet of annual evaporation.  It is entirely possible that more than 1000 surface acres of illegally filled ponds exist in the Upper Arkansas Basin.  If so, this would equate to more than 3000-acre feet of injury to water rights annually.  Injury to Arkansas River flows and water rights do not occur when entities or individuals appropriate water in priority or if out of priority make ​​replacements under existing laws through court decreed augmentation plans.  The problem occurs when entities or individuals take water out of priority without making replacements to the River.
 


2 Comments
Jeanne Herrick-Stare
10/29/2020 06:21:20 pm

How much money does the Water Conservancy District pull in each year by augmenting Nestle’s water usage? That’s an important element of your opinion of this important issue.

Reply
Ralph Scanga
10/30/2020 03:37:55 pm

First of all the water talks article about Nestle and augmentation is not my opinion but simply lays out the facts of augmentation and how they relate to anyone including Nestle's uses. The District's mission is the protection of water rights. Augmentation of out of priority depletions protect water rights from injury.
Anyone who uses water out of priority must by state law replace the depletion they cause. This requires obtaining a fully consumable source of water and a decreed plan of augmentation. Nestle is no exception. They must pay for their augmentation like everyone. They pay the water district $775 per acre foot of depletion to participate in our augmentation plan. Thanks for your interest in water.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    ABOUT

    Local water news by the Upper Arkansas Water Conservancy District

    Archives

    September 2024
    August 2023
    May 2023
    August 2022
    July 2022
    May 2022
    February 2022
    September 2021
    January 2021
    July 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018

    Categories

    All
    Events
    Forest Health
    Water News
    Water Talks

    RSS Feed

CONNECT

P.O. Box 1090
339 E. HWY 50
Salida, CO 81201

Phone: 719-539-5425
Fax: 719-539-7579

Hours:
9:00am- 12:00pm
1:00pm - 4:30pm

JOIN THE E-NEWSLETTER

    [object Object]
Submit
Submit Your Meter Reading
Update Contact Info
Ark Basin Streamflow
Ark Basin Snowpack

HELPFUL LINKS


UAWCD Technology Accessibility Statement
​UAWCD is committed to providing equitable access to our services to all Coloradans.
Our ongoing accessibility effort works towards being in line with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) version 2.1, level AA criteria. These guidelines not only help make technology accessible to users with sensory, cognitive and mobility disabilities, but ultimately to all users, regardless of ability.
Our efforts are just part of a meaningful change in making all State of Colorado and local government services inclusive and accessible. We welcome comments on how to improve our technology’s accessibility for users with disabilities and for requests for accommodations to any UAWCD services.
Requests for accommodations and feedback
We welcome your requests for accommodations and feedback about the accessibility of UAWCD’s online services. Please let us know if you encounter accessibility barriers. UAWCD is committed to responding as quickly as possible.
E-mail: [email protected]
Mail: P.O. Box 1090, Salida, CO 81201
Phone: 719-539-5425 (Written requests are preferred. If you are unable to submit your request in writing, you are welcome to contact us by telephone at this number.)